The magnet is so strong in the wing that I actually pulled the wing off of the magnetic base !!

The way the wings are attached to the magnet are faulty. They appeared to be glued. Magnet’s are too strong and the glue will not hold wing attached to the magnet.

The metal wings make the duck too noisy on still days. I swapped the metal wings to the plastic type which helped.

Purchased it for the metal wings, Because I thought they would be more durable. Made a clanking noise for about the first 45 minutes to an hour after turning on. On the third you said one of the wings broke. Due to poor design the wing is metal but the piece that connects it to the shaft is plastic I would not recommend someone to purchase this item. Other than that the items seem to be very well-made if I was to recommend another lucky duck it would not be this one it will be one with the plastic wings.